答案:(C) If this act was an attempt to seek the Catholic Church's approval, it was of no use.
先看空格前面。 前一句是 Ironically, Copernicus had dedicated his work to Pope Paul III.(諷刺的是,哥白尼曾把這部著作獻給教宗保祿三世。)
再看空格後面。 後面是 The Church ultimately banned De Revolutionibus, and the book remained on the list of forbidden reading material for nearly three centuries thereafter.(教會最終查禁了《天體運行論》,此後將近三百年,這本書一直列在禁書名單上。)
獻書給教宗、教會卻禁了這本書——Ironically(諷刺的是)指的就是這個落差,但落差要有一句話點破。 C 就是那一句:this act(這個舉動)回指獻書,of no use(沒有用)把獻書和禁書接起來。
Ironically 的落差還是沒有人點破;接著就跳到「教會最終禁了這本書」,中間少了「獻書有沒有用」這一步。A 是這一篇多出來的那一個。this act 回指獻書;Ironically 的兩頭A 講的事情和全篇完全相容——他確實一輩子都是教會中人,而且全篇一再出現天主教會。但五格都放不進去:
| 格 | 那一格在等什麼 | A 為什麼不行 |
|---|---|---|
| 35 | 獻書給教宗到底有沒有用 | A 補的是身分,跳過了這一步 |
共同點:A 說的是真的,也和主題有關,但每一格要的都是「承接前後兩句」的一句話,A 只是加了一項事實,兩頭都沒接上。
一個現成的旁證:學測 111 年參考試卷用同一篇文章改成 4 選 4,那一版的正文和四個選項裡都沒有這一句。
Copernicus, founder of modern astronomy, was born in 1473 to a well-to-do merchant family in Torun, Poland. He was sent off to attend university in Italy, studying mathematics and optics, and canon law. Returning from his studies abroad, Copernicus was appointed to an administrative position in the cathedral of Frauenburg. There he spent a sheltered and academic life for the rest of his days.
31 He made his observations from a tower situated on the protective wall around the cathedral. His observations were made with the “bare eyeball,” so to speak, as a hundred years were to pass before the invention of the telescope. In 1530, Copernicus completed his famous work De Revolutionibus, which later played a major role in changing the philosophical view of humankind’s place in the universe. 32 Copernicus died in 1543 and was never to know what a stir his work would cause. In his book, he asserted that the Earth rotated on its axis once daily and traveled around the Sun once yearly. 33 People then regarded the Earth as stationary, situated at the center of the universe, with the Sun and all the planets revolving around it. Copernicus’ theory challenged the long-held belief that God created the Heavens and the Earth, and could overturn the core values of the Catholic world. 34 Other ministers quickly followed suit, saying of Copernicus, “This fool wants to turn the whole art of astronomy upside down.”
Ironically, Copernicus had dedicated his work to Pope Paul III. 35If this act was an attempt to seek the Catholic Church's approval, it was of no use. The Church ultimately banned De Revolutionibus, and the book remained on the list of forbidden reading material for nearly three centuries thereafter.
現代天文學的奠基者哥白尼,一四七三年出生於波蘭托倫一個家境富裕的商人家庭。他被送到義大利念大學,修習數學、光學和教會法(教會內部的法律)。結束國外的學業回來之後,哥白尼被派到弗勞恩堡的大教堂擔任行政職務。此後他就在那裡度過受到庇護、與學術為伍的餘生。
31 他的觀測是在大教堂周圍防護牆上的一座塔樓進行的。可以說,他是用「肉眼」看的,因為望遠鏡要再過一百年才發明出來。一五三○年,哥白尼完成了他著名的《天體運行論》,這本書後來在改變人類看待自身在宇宙中位置的哲學觀上,扮演了重要的角色。32 哥白尼於一五四三年過世,始終不知道他的著作會掀起多大的波瀾。他在書中主張,地球每天繞著地軸自轉一圈,每年繞太陽公轉一圈。33 當時的人認為地球是靜止的,位在宇宙的中心,太陽和所有行星都繞著它轉。哥白尼的理論挑戰了長久以來「上帝創造天地」的信念,也可能顛覆天主教世界的核心價值。34 其他教士很快跟進,說哥白尼「這個蠢材想把整個天文學徹底翻過來」。
諷刺的是,哥白尼把這部著作獻給了教宗保祿三世。35 教會最終查禁了《天體運行論》,此後將近三個世紀,這本書一直留在禁書名單上。