答案:(C) For most of recorded human history, the open smile has been deeply unfashionable.
先看空格前面。 第一段最後一句是問句:But does this hold true across time and cultures?(但這在不同的時代和文化裡都成立嗎?)問句丟出兩個面向:時代和文化。
再看空格後面。 後面是 In the West, for example, portraits of men and women before the 1700s typically depicted them with a serious, unsmiling expression.(例如在西方,一七〇〇年代以前的人像畫,畫中人多半表情嚴肅、不帶笑容。)既然是舉例,前面一定有一句被它證明的話。
這個例子有兩個特徵:講的是過去、講的是不笑。空格裡那一句必須同時對上這兩點。C 的 For most of recorded human history(歷史上大多數時間)是時代,deeply unfashionable(很不受青睞)是不笑,而且正好接上問句的第一個面向。
In fact(事實上)開頭,這種詞是用來補強前一句已經說過的說法,而空格前面是一個問句,沒有說法可以補強。E 講的也是文化,不是時代。for example,先把那個例子的特徵一項一項列出來(講的是什麼時候?講的是什麼現象?),空格裡那一句必須每一項都對上。for exampleD 讀起來完全通順,主題也對——它就是在講微笑。但四個空格都放不下:
| 格 | 那一格在等什麼 | D 為什麼不行 |
|---|---|---|
| 31 | 一句「過去的人不笑」,好讓後面的肖像畫當例子 | D 沒有時代,也沒有「不笑」 |
看出共同點了嗎?全篇問的是「什麼東西影響了微笑」,D 答的是「微笑分成哪兩種」。這一年多出來的選項不是隨便湊的,它和正解同一個主題、卻是不同的切面。
Smiling is a gesture that many people engage in dozens of times a day without thought. Most people believe that smiling is an expression of good feelings, a simple way to show happiness and friendliness. But does this hold true across time and cultures?
31For most of recorded human history, the open smile has been deeply unfashionable. In the West, for example, portraits of men and women before the 1700s typically depicted them with a serious, unsmiling expression. The absence of smiles stemmed partly from the attempt to hide their decayed teeth caused by poor dental hygiene. More importantly, smiling and laughter had long been perceived in the society as manifestations of a lack of self-control and good manners. Paintings with white-toothed smiles emerged after the 1700s, with the gradual rise of a culture that valued perception and responsiveness.
Recent studies also show that interpretations of smiling may vary from culture to culture. While in most cultures smiling is associated with positive emotions, in certain cultures the same person can be judged as less intelligent when smiling. 32
The amount people smile is culturally influenced as well. People smile more when they are from countries that are high in individualism and low in population. These are often places where the needs and rights of the individual take precedence over those of the group. 33 Newcomers from different parts of the world are found to smile more. Without a shared language, they often resort to smiling to get along with others. For them, smiling is a straightforward way to indicate that one is reliable and trustworthy.
34 As many psychologists now point out, this simple gesture is in fact far more complicated than it may appear.
微笑是許多人一天做上幾十次、卻從來不會多想的一個動作。多數人相信微笑是好心情的表現,是表達快樂與友善最簡單的方式。但這件事在不同的時代、不同的文化裡都成立嗎?
31 以西方為例,一七○○年代以前的男女肖像畫,畫中人物通常表情嚴肅、不帶笑容。畫裡沒有笑容,一部分是為了遮掩因口腔衛生不良而蛀壞的牙齒。更重要的是,在當時的社會裡,微笑與大笑長久以來都被看成缺乏自制與教養的表現。露出白牙微笑的畫作要到一七○○年代之後才出現,當時社會逐漸興起一種文化,看重一個人能不能察覺別人的心思、並且做出回應。
近期的研究也顯示,各文化對微笑的解讀可能不同。在多數文化裡,微笑和正面情緒連在一起;但在某些文化裡,同一個人只要笑了,就可能被認為比較不聰明。32
人們笑的次數多寡同樣受文化影響。一個國家如果個人主義色彩濃、人口又少,那裡的人就笑得比較多。在這些地方,個人的需求與權利往往優先於群體。33 研究發現,來自世界各地的新移民笑得比較多。在沒有共同語言的情況下,他們常常靠微笑來和別人相處。對他們來說,微笑是最直接的方式,用來表示自己可靠、值得信任。
34 正如許多心理學家現在所指出的,這個看似簡單的動作,其實遠比表面上複雜得多。