閱讀測驗題庫 / 篇目一覽 / 94 指考

94 指考閱讀測驗:湯普森醫生的演講失敗

Dr. Thompson's Unsuccessful Speech
指考 94年第 50–53 題4 題

先讀文章、作答下方的題目,再展開後面的「看答案、依據句與逐段中譯」和「這一篇的生字表」。也可以到互動練習線上作答,交卷後自動批改。

文章

第 1 段Dr. Thompson was pleased. Just three months after moving to the small Midwestern town, he had been invited to address an evening meeting of the Chamber of Commerce. Here was the perfect opportunity to show his knowledge of modern medicine and to get his practice off to a flourishing start. With this in mind, the doctor prepared carefully.

第 2 段On the night of his speech, Dr. Thompson was delighted to see that the meeting hall was full. After being introduced, he strode confidently to the lectern and announced his topic: “Recent Advances in Medicine.” He began with a detailed discussion of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, a rare brain disorder that had recently been covered in the New England Journal of Medicine. Next he outlined the progress that had been made in studying immune system disorders.

第 3 段Just about this time, halfway through his speech, Dr. Thompson began to notice a certain restlessness in his audience. People were murmuring and shuffling their feet. Someone in the fourth row seemed to be glancing at a newspaper. Nevertheless, Dr. Thompson plowed on. He had saved the best for last. He quoted extensively from an article in the Lancet about genetic research, feeling sure his audience would be impressed by his familiarity with this prestigious British medical journal.

第 4 段Then the speech was over. Dr. Thompson had expected to be surrounded by enthusiastic people, congratulating him and asking questions. Instead he found himself standing alone. Finally the president of the Chamber of Commerce came up to him. “Something tells me,” said Dr. Thompson, “that my speech was not very successful. I can’t understand it. I worked so hard to make it interesting.” “Oh, it was a fine speech,” replied the president. “But maybe it would have gone over better with a different audience. Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is not exactly a factor in these people’s everyday experience. You know, here we are in January. If you’d talked about ways to avoid getting the flu, you’d have had them on the edge of their seats!”

題目

50.What is the main message of the passage?

  1. (A)A good speaker has to be fully prepared regardless of the audience.
  2. (B)A good speaker should display his learning to the audience in an enthusiastic way.
  3. (C)The more a speaker wants to please the audience, the more likely he will succeed.
  4. (D)The key to a successful speech is to make it meaningful and relevant to the audience.
🐛 回報這題的錯誤(題目編號 Rz94_50)

51.What was the reaction of the audience to Dr. Thompson’s speech?

  1. (A)They were bored because the medical topics were not their daily concern.
  2. (B)They did not understand him so they could only discuss among themselves.
  3. (C)They were impressed by his familiarity with advanced research in medicine.
  4. (D)They congratulated him on the success of the speech and asked him questions.
🐛 回報這題的錯誤(題目編號 Rz94_51)

52.Which topic was NOT mentioned in the doctor’s speech?

  1. (A)Genetic research.
  2. (B)Flu.
  3. (C)Immune system disorder.
  4. (D)Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease.
🐛 回報這題的錯誤(題目編號 Rz94_52)

53.What does “had them on the edge of their seats” mean in the last sentence of the passage?

  1. (A)Had them stand up.
  2. (B)Took them by surprise.
  3. (C)Caught their full attention.
  4. (D)Aroused their suspicion.
🐛 回報這題的錯誤(題目編號 Rz94_53)
看答案、依據句與逐段中譯
題號官方答案答對率鑑別度
50(D)61%66
51(A)50%79
52(B)57%63
53(C)59%55

答對率與鑑別度出處:大考中心 94 學年度指定科目考試統計圖表:英文科答對率及鑑別指數表

每一題的依據句

第 50 題 主旨題 Main idea

依據句:全文要讀完整篇才能判斷,不在某一句裡。

第 1 段說湯普森醫師受邀在商會演講,想藉這個機會展現醫學知識,準備得很用心;第 2–3 段說他談庫賈氏病、免疫系統疾病和基因研究,講到一半聽眾就坐不住了,他還是照樣講完;第 4 段說演講結束後沒有人圍上來,會長點出原因:庫賈氏病跟聽眾的日常生活沾不上邊,要是談怎麼預防流感,大家就會全神貫注。所以演講要成功,內容要對聽眾有意義、跟他們切身相關,是 (D)。(A) 偏離主題,湯普森醫師準備得非常用心,卻因為沒有考慮聽眾而失敗,文章要說的正好相反;(B) 偏離主題,向聽眾展現學問正是湯普森醫師做的事,結果聽眾並不感興趣;(C) 偏離主題,文章談的是內容要切合聽眾,不是越想討好聽眾就越容易成功。
錯誤選項怎麼錯
(A)偏離主題用了原文的字詞第 1 段說湯普森醫師準備得很用心,第 4 段卻說演講不成功,原因是內容和聽眾的生活無關,文章談的不是不管聽眾是誰都要充分準備。
(B)偏離主題用了原文的字詞第 2、3 段的湯普森醫師正是在聽眾面前展現學問,結果聽眾坐不住,第 4 段才說要談他們切身的話題。
(C)偏離主題文章談的是演講內容要切合聽眾,不是越想討好聽眾就越容易成功。
誘答類型是什麼?
誘答類型是指錯誤選項「錯在哪一類」。主旨題看範圍:過於狹隘是只講到文章的一部分,過於廣泛是講得比文章大,偏離主題是談的不是全文的重點。推論題看說法:張冠李戴是把這件事的說法放到另一件事上,以偏概全是把一部分說成全部,無中生有是文章沒提、也推不出來,說法太過武斷是講得比文章更絕對,與原文相反是意思顛倒,是事實,不是意見是選項本身符合原文,但題目要選的是意見。問段落順序的題目也用推論題這一組。「最多人選」的百分比,是大考中心公布的全體考生選答率。
「過於狹隘」「過於廣泛」「偏離主題」是教學現場與本題庫的通行說法,不是論文的分類。
參考資料:黃品瑄(2022)。《2018 至 2022 年學測和指考英文閱讀測驗困難題目之分析》〔碩士論文〕。國立政治大學英國語文學系。該研究分析 28 道困難題,指出誘答選項常含與文章無關的背景知識,或用了文章中出現過的字詞。〈論文連結〉。選答率出處:大考中心各年度學科能力測驗統計圖表〈各科選擇題選項分析〉。
錯誤選項:(A) 偏離主題;(B) 偏離主題;(C) 偏離主題
第 51 題 細節題 Supporting details

第 3 段People were murmuring and shuffling their feet.

第 4 段Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is not exactly a factor in these people’s everyday experience.

原文 → 答案
everyday experience → daily concern
這一題答對率只有 50%,聽眾的反應要把兩段合起來看。判斷步驟:[1] 第 3 段說聽眾竊竊私語、腳動來動去,還有人在看報紙,這是聽得不耐煩、覺得無聊的樣子;[2] 第 4 段會長點出原因:庫賈氏病跟這些人的日常生活(everyday experience)沾不上邊;[3] 選項把日常生活換成 daily concern,所以是 (A)。(C) 照抄第 3 段的 impressed,以為聽眾會佩服他的,是湯普森醫師自己的想法,不是聽眾的反應;(D) 照抄第 4 段的 congratulating,那是湯普森醫師原本以為會發生的事,實際上沒有人上前道賀;(B) 原文沒有說聽眾聽不懂,竊竊私語是因為沒興趣。
第 52 題 細節題(未提及) Supporting details

第 2 段He began with a detailed discussion of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease

第 2 段Next he outlined the progress that had been made in studying immune system disorders.

第 3 段He quoted extensively from an article in the Lancet about genetic research

演講裡談到的三個題目,原文依序是:第 2 段先談 Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease,就是 (D);接著談 immune system disorders,就是 (C);第 3 段引用《刺胳針》上 genetic research 的文章,就是 (A)。流感(flu)出現在第 4 段,是會長說他可以談的題目,湯普森醫師並沒有講,所以是 (B)。
第 53 題 詞義題 Vocabulary in context

第 4 段If you’d talked about ways to avoid getting the flu, you’d have had them on the edge of their seats!

會長拿湯普森醫師的演講來對照:聽眾對庫賈氏病沒興趣,要是談怎麼預防流感,就會 on the edge of their seats。人坐到椅子邊緣、身體往前傾,是聽得入神、想知道接下來說什麼的樣子,所以是 (C) 吸引他們全部的注意力。(A) 站起來,是照字面想成離開座位;(B) 讓他們嚇一跳,原文沒有出乎意料的意思;(D) 引起懷疑,跟會長的意思相反。

逐段中譯

第 1 段湯普森醫師很高興。他搬到中西部這個小鎮才三個月,就受邀在商會的晚間聚會上演講。這正是展現他現代醫學知識的大好機會,也能讓他的診所一開業就生意興隆。想到這裡,湯普森醫師準備得非常用心。

第 2 段演講那天晚上,湯普森醫師看到會場座無虛席,非常高興。主持人介紹完以後,他自信滿滿地走上講台,宣布講題:「醫學的最新進展」。他先詳細討論庫賈氏病,這是一種罕見的腦部疾病,《新英格蘭醫學期刊》最近才報導過。接著,他概述免疫系統疾病研究的進展。

第 3 段大約就在這時候,演講講到一半,湯普森醫師開始察覺聽眾有點坐不住。大家在竊竊私語,腳在地上動來動去,第四排有個人好像在看報紙。儘管如此,湯普森醫師還是硬著頭皮講下去,因為他把最精彩的部分留在最後。他大量引用英國權威醫學期刊《刺胳針》上一篇基因研究的文章,心想聽眾一定會佩服他對這本期刊這麼熟悉。

第 4 段演講結束了。湯普森醫師原本以為會有一群熱情的聽眾圍上來,向他道賀、發問,結果他卻發現自己孤零零地站在那裡。最後,商會會長走了過來。湯普森醫師說:「我有種感覺,這場演講好像不太成功。我實在想不通,我花了好大的力氣,想讓演講有趣一點。」會長回答:「噢,演講內容很好,只是換一群聽眾,效果可能會好一些。庫賈氏病跟這些人的日常生活實在沾不上邊。你知道,現在是一月,要是你談的是怎麼預防流感,大家一定聽得全神貫注!」

全文中心思想與段落主旨句

兩者都是 全文中心思想 段落主旨句
藍底標示全文中心思想,底線標示段落主旨句,一句同時是兩者,就用藍底加底線。這一篇沒有一句話直接點出全文中心思想,各段也都沒有主旨句。請對照「這一篇的文章結構」裡的綱要,找出各段的重點,再看第 50 題(主旨題)的解析,了解怎麼從各段歸納出全文的主旨。
📌 提醒:不是每一段都有主旨句。開頭鋪陳的段落、承接前一段的延伸段落,還有敘事或描寫的段落,主旨常常藏在字裡行間,找不到一句可以直接畫線。遇到這種段落,與其硬找一句話,不如問自己「這一段在做什麼」(舉例?補充?延續前一段?),再用自己的話歸納出這一段的重點就可以了。
這一篇的文章結構
文體記敘文 Narrative
組織方式時序發展 Chronological這一類怎麼辨識 →
關鍵轉折詞With this in mindNextNeverthelessThenInsteadFinallyBut
綱要
  1. 湯普森醫師搬到中西部小鎮三個月,受邀在商會演講,他認為這是展現現代醫學知識、讓診所生意興隆的好機會,(With this in mind) 所以準備得很用心。
  2. 他以「醫學最新進展」為題,先談罕見的腦部疾病庫賈氏病,(Next) 再談免疫系統疾病的研究進展。
  3. 講到一半,聽眾開始騷動、竊竊私語,(Nevertheless) 他照樣講下去,最後大量引用英國權威醫學期刊《刺胳針》(Lancet)的基因研究,以為聽眾會佩服他熟悉這份期刊。
  4. (Then) 演講結束了,他以為熱情的聽眾會圍上來祝賀、發問,(Instead) 結果卻只有他一個人站在那裡。
  5. (Finally) 商會會長走過來,說演講很好,(But) 只是換一群聽眾效果可能比較好:庫賈氏病和這些人的日常生活沾不上邊,現在又是一月,要是談怎麼預防流感,大家一定聽得全神貫注。
括號裡是原文的轉折詞或關鍵字句,可以回文章找出它們的位置。綱要依內容分點,不一定和段落一一對應。
這一篇的生字表 (關鍵字彙 11 個、參考字彙 12 個、字詞搭配 16 組)
生字表分成三部分:關鍵字彙、參考字彙和字詞搭配。前兩部分的級數都依大考中心《高中英文參考詞彙表》(111 學年度起適用)。大考中心的考試說明寫到,學測的詞彙以第一到第五級為主,偶爾會用到第六級以上的字(〈學科能力測驗英文考科考試說明〉)。「關鍵字彙」是這一篇裡第三到第五級、而且在歷屆學測或指考詞彙題的選項裡出現過的字(答案和誘答都算);每個字下面列出考過的題目,點題號可以到學測單字題庫或指考單字題庫作答,考的字形和這一篇不同時,題號後面寫出考的字形。「參考字彙」是其他比較難的字:詞彙題還沒考過的第五級字、第六級的字,以及詞彙表沒有收錄的字(標「表外」)。第一、二級的字比較基本,不列。字後面的中括號是 KK 音標(美式發音)。中文寫的是這個字在這一篇裡的意思,不是字典列的全部意思。文中的字形和詞彙表不一樣時,括號裡寫詞彙表收的字,查字典時查這個字。人名、地名這類專有名詞,詞彙表不收錄,這裡也不列。

關鍵字彙 第三到第五級、詞彙題考過的字

參考字彙 詞彙題沒考過的五級字、六級字、詞彙表外的字

  • flourishing (詞彙表:flourish)[ˈflɝɪʃɪŋ]adj.興旺的、生意興隆的六級第 1 段
  • stride[straɪd]v.大步走六級第 2 段
  • lectern[ˈlɛktɚn]n.講台、演講台表外第 2 段
  • immune[ɪˈmjun]adj.免疫的(immune system 免疫系統)五級第 2 段
  • halfway[ˈhæfˈweɪ]adv.在中途、到一半表外第 3 段
  • shuffle[ˈʃʌfəl]v.拖著(腳)動來動去六級第 3 段
  • plow[plaʊ]v.(plow on)硬著頭皮繼續做下去六級第 3 段
  • genetic[ʤəˈnɛtɪk]adj.基因的、遺傳的五級第 3 段
  • familiarity[fəˌmɪliˈærəti]n.熟悉六級第 3 段
  • prestigious[prɛˈstɪʤəs]adj.有聲望的、權威的表外第 3 段
  • regardless[rɪˈgɑrdləs]adv.(regardless of)不管、不論五級第 50 題
  • arouse[əˈraʊz]v.引起、喚起五級第 53 題

字詞搭配 配對與接法

「字詞搭配」是要整組記的說法,分兩種:一種是哪兩個字配在一起,例如 pose a serious risk(造成嚴重的風險)、in unison(齊聲),換成意思相近的字就不自然;另一種是這個字後面要接什麼,寫成公式,例如 be resistant to + N(對……有抵抗力)。公式裡的 + N 表示接名詞,+ V 接原形動詞,+ V-ing 接動名詞,sb 指人,sth 指事物,「時間」「地方」這類中文表示那裡要填的東西。名稱不必背,看得出這一條寫的是「配對」還是「接法」就夠了;記住搭配和接法,這個字你才用得出來,不會只是看得懂。一看就懂的組合和專有名詞不列。每一條寫的是查字典時的基本形,文中的寫法不同時,下面附上原文。
  • address a meeting在會議上演講第 1 段原文:to address an evening meeting
  • get + sth + off to a + adj. + start讓……有個……的開始第 1 段原文:to get his practice off to a flourishing start
  • with + sth + in mind心裡想著……第 1 段原文:With this in mind
  • be delighted to + V很高興……第 2 段原文:was delighted to see
  • a discussion of + N對……的討論第 2 段原文:a detailed discussion of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease
  • make progress in + V-ing在……方面有進展第 2 段原文:the progress that had been made in studying
  • halfway through + N……進行到一半第 3 段原文:halfway through his speech
  • shuffle one's feet兩腳動來動去第 3 段原文:shuffling their feet
  • plow on硬著頭皮繼續第 3 段原文:Dr. Thompson plowed on
  • save the best for last把最好的留到最後第 3 段原文:He had saved the best for last
  • be impressed by + N對……印象深刻第 3 段原文:would be impressed by his familiarity
  • familiarity with + N對……的熟悉第 3 段原文:his familiarity with this prestigious British medical journal
  • find oneself + V-ing發現自己……第 4 段原文:he found himself standing alone
  • come up to + sb走向某人第 4 段原文:came up to him
  • go over well with + sb讓某人聽了很喜歡第 4 段原文:would have gone over better with a different audience
  • have + sb + on the edge of one's seat讓某人聽得入迷第 4 段原文:you’d have had them on the edge of their seats
到互動練習作答這一篇 →